September 29, 2008 – 2:53 am
I know that the purpose of praise and worship is to worship God, not to start thinking technically and analyze it. In any case, I can’t help doing the latter. So here I will compare 5 different p&w. I have only been to each of the 3 churches once, so it’s probably not a very accurate reflection of their overall p&w. Stated then, is what I happened to see on one particular Sunday. Note: This is just my opinion, hope nobody gets offended. And also, most of the churches are typical Baptist, quite traditional)
Union Chapels
Voices: Male (lead), female (harmonizing)
Instruments: piano (worship leader), drums, bass, acoustic guitar, keyboard (for organ-ish sounds), violin (occasionally)
The Good: The voices. Sounds really good, especially when there’s the harmonizing part - the female voice doesn’t have to stretch too high for songs like ‘From the Inside Out’. Instruments are also played very well, especially piano and drums. Violin, when used, is just simply beautiful - great short instrumental breaks. I love the hymns too - great that they sing hymns in a new beautiful way.
The Mediocre aka Can-Be-Improved: Not much variation in style - as in it is always the piano starting the song.
Youth Worship back home
Voices: Varies. Usually 2 female, one male
Instruments: Piano, drums, electric guitar, acoustic guitar, bass
The Good: Instruments probably form the best part here, since it’s a very contemporary assortment of instruments.
The Mediocre aka CBI: Singing. Haven’t yet found one really good singer. Instrument-playing quality can also vary quite a lot - but it’s good that others can be trained.
Church #1
Voices: Two males
Instruments: Piano, organ
The Good: Hm. I guess the singer is pretty good.
The Mediocre aka CBI: Instrument variation. Also, they were singing a too-fast version of ‘I Could Sing Of Your Love’, which was totally weird.
Church #2
Voices: 6 females (one worship leader), one male
Instruments: Piano (worship leader), some sort of sit-on drum, electric guitar, violin, recorders, etc.
The Good: Now that is quite a variety of instruments. Interesting. More lively singing and playing compared to the others (except YW).
The Mediocre aka CBI: So many female voices can be quite a jarring sound. You know, the sharp piercing highness of it all. It’s ok though, just weird.
Church #3
Voices: 2 females (one worship leader), one male
Instruments: Keyboard, drums, acoustic guitar, electric guitar, bass
The Good: Ah! Now there’s a more contemporary p&w, somewhat resembling the make of YW. Great music, not very outstanding, but everything blends well together. They even look professional with all the headphones!
The Mediocre aka CBI: The voices are not exceptional, especially that the worship leader’s voice doesn’t stand out that much. But still great singing. Overall, this church has the best p&w - and of course, quite an unfair comparison to the others since this church is obviously much more contemporary - it isn’t a real Baptist church.
Well, that’s it. I will say that Church #3’s p&w is the best, Union chapels come in a very close second, and YW’s sits comfortably at 3rd. Although really, they could use some improvement in the singing. But still, we can all worship God, no matter how good the p&w is, no matter the style. God looks at the heart - and I will confess that in doing this analysis, it wasn’t really the heart. All in the brain. I’m sorry.
Posted in Church, Music |
2 Comments »